The Real Cost of Health Insurance: Exploring Critical Challenges for U.S. Families
February 24, 2025
In-depth

In February 2025, Count on Mothers examined U.S. families' experiences with health insurance affordability, coverage, and access to care. Drawing on a nationally representative survey of mothers across regions and the political spectrum, the study addressed five core questions: who drives healthcare decisions, rates of denied and delayed care, the administrative burden on families, differences between private and public insurance experiences, and the health and financial consequences for families. Findings describe systemic challenges in the current health insurance landscape — particularly among families with private insurance.

Related themes:

Shared Priorities and Cross-Partisan Alignment Among Mothers

Family Economic Security and Cost Pressures

Child and Family Mental Health Access and Support

  • Administrative burden is widespread:
    Nearly 65% of mothers report struggling with excessive paperwork and authorization hurdles to access essential care, with burdens more pronounced among families with private insurance.
  • Insurance companies often override medical judgment:
    More than half of mothers (54%) say insurance companies exert more control over healthcare decisions than doctors, and 60% of these mothers report that their family’s health has suffered as a result.
  • Denied and delayed care cause real harm:
    About 45% of mothers report that an insurance decision harmed their family’s health, and a similar share report being denied treatments they believed should have been covered.
  • Delays are strongly linked to negative health outcomes:
    Among mothers forced to delay or forgo care due to insurance requirements, 72% report adverse health effects, compared with 22% among those who did not experience delays.
  • Private insurance is associated with worse outcomes:
    Families with private—especially self-paid—insurance report higher denial rates, greater administrative burdens, and more frequent negative health impacts than those covered by Medicaid or Medicare.

Source: Count on Mothers, The Real Cost of Health Insurance: Exploring Critical Challenges for U.S. Families, February 2025. Nationally representative survey of 6,073 U.S. mothers across all 50 states and Washington, D.C., weighted across political ideology and region (sample composition compared to Gallup national averages and U.S. Census Bureau distributions). Research led by a PhD-credentialed researcher and an MPH data scientist.

Research Library

Explore Count on Mothers reports — rapid polls and in-depth national studies.

Methodology
Count on Mothers conducts nationally representative research with U.S. mothers, weighted to reflect the population and reported in aggregate. Research is led by a PhD + MPH team. Findings have informed policy, industry, and media, and entered the Congressional Record on childcare, paid leave, and technology policy.
Rapid Poll

Issues that Matter Most to Mothers

From January through July 2024, Count on Mothers identified the issues mothers most want federal policymakers to address related to their children's health and safety. The two-stage study began with an open-ended question to mothers over six months, then tested the emerging themes through a structured follow-up survey of mothers across regions and the political spectrum. Five issues consistently rose to the top — substance use, abortion and reproductive health, healthcare access and cost, food access and nutrition, and childcare affordability — with striking consistency across geography, education, and ideology in both what mothers prioritize and the underlying stresses shaping family life.
July 31, 2024
View Report →
Rapid Poll

Mothers' Views on Big Business and Trust

In June 2024, Count on Mothers examined mothers' views on major industries and corporate accountability — identifying which sectors mothers find most concerning for families and capturing open-ended feedback directed at corporate leaders. Drawing on a nationally representative sample of mothers across regions and the political spectrum, the survey measured industry-level concern, sentiment toward business leadership, and the institutional pressure points families navigate daily. Mothers showed strong cross-partisan alignment on deep mistrust of corporate decision-making, with consistent concern that profit is prioritized over children's safety and family well-being.
June 28, 2024
View Report →
In-depth

The Impact of Childcare Costs on Families' Financial Security

In May 2024, Count on Mothers examined how childcare costs and access shape U.S. families' financial security — including effects on savings, work hours, net income, career advancement, and long-term earning potential. Drawing on a national sample of mothers across regions and the political spectrum, the survey combined eight quantitative measures with an open-ended question inviting mothers to propose solutions. Findings show that childcare costs exert significant pressure on family finances, employment decisions, and long-term economic security — with patterns largely consistent across the political spectrum.
May 31, 2024
View Report →
Rapid Poll

Mothers' Views on the PROTECT Act and Youth Vaping Recommendations

In April 2024, Count on Mothers examined mothers' views on federal recommendations for regulating e-cigarettes — including provisions from the PROTECT Act and the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations' Youth Vaping Epidemic Report — a study requested by the Subcommittee, led by Senator Richard Blumenthal. Drawing on a nationally representative sample of mothers across regions and the political spectrum, the survey captured firsthand experience with youth vaping and access to e-cigarette products. Mothers showed strong cross-partisan support for strengthened federal research, regulation, and enforcement to reduce youth e-cigarette use.
April 30, 2024
View Report →
To learn more about partnerships, visit Partner With Us
Exploring how independent benchmark data could inform your work?
Partner With Us