The Real Cost of Health Insurance: Exploring Critical Challenges for U.S. Families
February 24, 2025
In-depth

In February 2025, Count on Mothers examined U.S. families' experiences with health insurance affordability, coverage, and access to care. Drawing on a nationally representative survey of mothers across regions and the political spectrum, the study addressed five core questions: who drives healthcare decisions, rates of denied and delayed care, the administrative burden on families, differences between private and public insurance experiences, and the health and financial consequences for families. Findings describe systemic challenges in the current health insurance landscape — particularly among families with private insurance.

Related themes:

Shared Priorities and Cross-Partisan Alignment Among Mothers

Family Economic Security and Cost Pressures

Child and Family Mental Health Access and Support

  • Administrative burden is widespread:
    Nearly 65% of mothers report struggling with excessive paperwork and authorization hurdles to access essential care, with burdens more pronounced among families with private insurance.
  • Insurance companies often override medical judgment:
    More than half of mothers (54%) say insurance companies exert more control over healthcare decisions than doctors, and 60% of these mothers report that their family’s health has suffered as a result.
  • Denied and delayed care cause real harm:
    About 45% of mothers report that an insurance decision harmed their family’s health, and a similar share report being denied treatments they believed should have been covered.
  • Delays are strongly linked to negative health outcomes:
    Among mothers forced to delay or forgo care due to insurance requirements, 72% report adverse health effects, compared with 22% among those who did not experience delays.
  • Private insurance is associated with worse outcomes:
    Families with private—especially self-paid—insurance report higher denial rates, greater administrative burdens, and more frequent negative health impacts than those covered by Medicaid or Medicare.

Source: Count on Mothers, The Real Cost of Health Insurance: Exploring Critical Challenges for U.S. Families, February 2025. Nationally representative survey of 6,073 U.S. mothers across all 50 states and Washington, D.C., weighted across political ideology and region (sample composition compared to Gallup national averages and U.S. Census Bureau distributions). Research led by a PhD-credentialed researcher and an MPH data scientist.

Research Library

Explore Count on Mothers reports — rapid polls and in-depth national studies.

Methodology
Count on Mothers conducts nationally representative research with U.S. mothers, weighted to reflect the population and reported in aggregate. Research is led by a PhD + MPH team. Findings have informed policy, industry, and media, and entered the Congressional Record on childcare, paid leave, and technology policy.
In-depth

Insights into American Mothers' Views on Baby Food Product Safety

This report examines mothers’ concerns about heavy metals and other contaminants in baby and toddler food, drawing on a national survey conducted in collaboration with the Clean Label Project. Nearly 1,000 mothers across the U.S. shared how they assess infant food safety, their awareness of legislative efforts such as California’s AB 899, and where they seek trusted information. Findings show widespread concern about food contaminants, strong support for transparency and regulation, and a notable gap between mothers’ concern and their awareness of existing policy initiatives.
November 29, 2024
View Report →
Rapid Poll

Mothers' Views on the Safe School Meals Act

In October 2024, Count on Mothers examined mothers' views on the Safe School Meals Act, federal legislation introduced in the U.S. Senate in September 2024 to strengthen FDA food safety standards for school meals. Drawing on a nationally representative sample of mothers across regions and the political spectrum, the survey evaluated the bill's six main provisions — FDA limits on heavy metals, bans on pesticide residues, restrictions on harmful packaging chemicals, food additive reevaluation, grants for farmers and manufacturers to transition to safer practices, and mothers' trust in current FDA standards.
October 31, 2024
View Report →
Rapid Poll

Mothers' Views on the U.S. Education Climate

In September 2024, Count on Mothers examined mothers' views and firsthand experiences with U.S. public schools, including school enrollment patterns, trust in teachers and administrators, perceptions of school environment, and interest in switching school types. Drawing on a nationally representative sample of mothers across regions and the political spectrum, the survey captured five core dimensions of mothers' relationship to public education and an open-ended question on the most important problem to solve in their district's public schools. Mothers reported broadly positive views of public schools alongside specific, persistent concerns — most prominently bullying, safety, and administrative accountability.
September 30, 2024
View Report →
Rapid Poll

Mothers' Views on the Bipartisan Childcare Package

In August 2024, Count on Mothers examined mothers' views on two bipartisan, bicameral childcare bills introduced by Senators Katie Britt (R-AL) and Tim Kaine (D-VA) — the Childcare Availability and Affordability Act and the Childcare Workforce Act. Drawing on a nationally representative sample of mothers across regions and the political spectrum, the survey evaluated proposed increases to the Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit, expanded Dependent Care Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs), and employer tax credits — alongside firsthand experience using these benefits and assessments of which policy mechanisms would most effectively support families.
August 30, 2024
View Report →
To learn more about partnerships, visit Partner With Us
Exploring how independent benchmark data could inform your work?
Partner With Us