The Real Cost of Health Insurance: Exploring Critical Challenges for U.S. Families
In-depth

This report analyzes responses from 6,073 mothers across all 50 states and the political spectrum to examine the real-world impact of health insurance on families’ access to care and financial security. Conducted in collaboration with News Not Noise following widespread public sharing of insurance-related hardships, the study documents the prevalence of administrative barriers, denied and delayed care, and resulting health harms—particularly among families with private insurance. Findings highlight systemic challenges in the current health insurance landscape and their consequences for family well-being.

February 24, 2025
Related themes:

Shared Priorities and Cross-Partisan Alignment Among Mothers

Family Economic Security and Cost Pressures

Child and Family Mental Health Access and Support

  • Administrative burden is widespread:
    Nearly 65% of mothers report struggling with excessive paperwork and authorization hurdles to access essential care, with burdens more pronounced among families with private insurance.
  • Insurance companies often override medical judgment:
    More than half of mothers (54%) say insurance companies exert more control over healthcare decisions than doctors, and 60% of these mothers report that their family’s health has suffered as a result.
  • Denied and delayed care cause real harm:
    About 45% of mothers report that an insurance decision harmed their family’s health, and a similar share report being denied treatments they believed should have been covered.
  • Delays are strongly linked to negative health outcomes:
    Among mothers forced to delay or forgo care due to insurance requirements, 72% report adverse health effects, compared with 22% among those who did not experience delays.
  • Private insurance is associated with worse outcomes:
    Families with private—especially self-paid—insurance report higher denial rates, greater administrative burdens, and more frequent negative health impacts than those covered by Medicaid or Medicare.

This report analyzes responses from 6,073 mothers across all 50 states and the political spectrum to examine the real-world impact of health insurance on families’ access to care and financial security. Conducted in collaboration with News Not Noise following widespread public sharing of insurance-related hardships, the study documents the prevalence of administrative barriers, denied and delayed care, and resulting health harms—particularly among families with private insurance. Findings highlight systemic challenges in the current health insurance landscape and their consequences for family well-being.

This report focuses on information Count on Mothers collected in January 2025. The study seeks to answer these pressing questions: Are there real and significant burdens placed on families by health insurance policies? What are the rates and impacts of harm, if any? And most importantly, what changes could make a meaningful difference for American families? This report explores the real costs of health insurance by analyzing the challenges U.S.families face when navigating the complex healthcare system with an eye toward solutions.  A total of 6073 mothers residing in 50 states and across the political spectrum provided feedback based on their firsthand knowledge. Regarding the political background of the survey respondents, the sample closely reflects the U.S. breakdown of political ideology among women according to Gallup. After analyzing Mothers’ opinions from the survey, we take this aggregate data and share it with industry leaders, policymakers, and the public so they are educated on Mothers’ firsthand experiences, needs, and concerns.

Research Library

Explore Count on Mothers reports — rapid polls and in-depth national studies.

Methodology
Count on Mothers conducts nationwide surveys and qualitative research with U.S. mothers. Findings are analyzed and reported in aggregate to inform research publications and decision-making related to families.
Rapid

Mothers' Views on the Childcare for Working Families Act

In September 2023, Count on Mothers surveyed 354 mothers across 47 states and a broad range of political ideologies to understand parental perspectives on the Child Care for Working Families Act (S.1354). In addition to the national survey, six mothers from conservative, moderate, and liberal backgrounds participated in in-depth interviews to provide qualitative context. Findings were shared with the public and Congressional legislators to inform deliberations on policies affecting children and families. Overall, mothers across the political spectrum expressed strong support for the bill, with some variation by ideology on specific provisions.
September 30, 2023
View Report →
Rapid

Mothers' Views on the FAMILY Act

In August 2023, Count on Mothers surveyed 309 mothers across 41 states and a broad range of political ideologies to understand parental perspectives on the FAMILY (Family and Medical Insurance Leave) Act (S.1714). Mothers shared their views based on first-hand experience with health, caregiving, and work-related leave. The aggregated findings were shared with the public and Congressional legislators to inform deliberations on policies affecting children and families. Overall, mothers across political backgrounds showed strong alignment on core paid leave protections, with some variation on specific provisions.
August 31, 2023
View Report →
Rapid

Parents Bill of Rights

In July 2023, Count on Mothers surveyed 277 mothers across 44 states and a broad range of political ideologies to understand parental views on the Parents Bill of Rights (H.R.5). Mothers responded based on their first-hand experience with public education and family decision-making. The aggregated findings were shared with Congressional legislators to inform deliberations on policies affecting children and families. Overall, mothers across political backgrounds showed strong agreement on many core provisions of the bill, while expressing mixed views on several specific implementation measures.
July 31, 2023
View Report →
Rapid

Mothers' Views on Social Media Legislation

In June 2023, 318 mothers from 44 states and a cross-section of political ideology completed a short anonymous survey and shared their views on the components of the “Protecting Kids on Social Media Act.” We take this aggregate data and share it with Congressional legislators so they are educated while deliberating over this bill. Mothers share their views based on their first-hand experience with the issues the bill seeks to address.
June 30, 2023
View Report →
Interested in commissioning research or receiving a briefing?
Partner With Us