The PROTECT Act and Recommendations from the Youth Vaping Epidemic Report
Rapid

In April 2024, Count on Mothers surveyed 595 mothers across 49 states and a broad range of political ideologies to understand their views on federal recommendations for regulating e-cigarettes, including provisions from the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations report and the PROTECT Act. Mothers shared perspectives based on firsthand experience with youth vaping and access to e-cigarette products. Aggregated findings were shared with the Senate Subcommittee and the public to inform ongoing policy discussions. Overall, mothers across the political spectrum expressed strong agreement on the need for strengthened federal research, regulation, and enforcement to reduce youth e-cigarette use.

April 30, 2024
Related themes:

Family Economic Security and Cost Pressures

Shared Priorities and Cross-Partisan Alignment Among Mothers

  • Strong support for federal research and education:
    More than 78% of mothers agreed that the CDC should be authorized to invest $500 million over five years in research and education to reduce youth e-cigarette use.
  • Broad agreement on restricting flavored products:
    Large majorities of mothers across political ideologies supported enforcing restrictions on flavored e-cigarettes that promote youth initiation, with support ranging from 86% among very conservative mothers to over 97% among very liberal mothers.
  • Consensus on updating marketing regulations:
    Between 87% and 91% of mothers agreed that federal laws governing the marketing of age-restricted products should be updated to reflect current advertising and promotional practices.
  • Support for evaluating social media safeguards:
    Over 80% of mothers agreed that Congress should assess the effectiveness of social media age-gating tools and require companies to strengthen protections for minors.
  • Concerns about access and enforcement:
    Mothers frequently cited easy access to vaping products, inadequate ID checks, and purchases through adults as key concerns, alongside calls for stronger education efforts and stricter laws to limit youth exposure.

In April 2024, Count on Mothers surveyed 595 mothers across 49 states and a broad range of political ideologies to understand their views on federal recommendations for regulating e-cigarettes, including provisions from the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations report and the PROTECT Act. Mothers shared perspectives based on firsthand experience with youth vaping and access to e-cigarette products. Aggregated findings were shared with the Senate Subcommittee and the public to inform ongoing policy discussions. Overall, mothers across the political spectrum expressed strong agreement on the need for strengthened federal research, regulation, and enforcement to reduce youth e-cigarette use.

Main Takeaways
Quantitative Questions
Over 78% of Mothers agreed
(either agreed or strongly agreed) that there should be a CDC initiative that authorizes $500 million over 5 years for enhanced research and education to reduce youth use of e-cigarettes. An overwhelming majority of mothers agreed that there should be enforced restriction of flavored e-cigarette products that promote youth tobacco product initiation and long-term use, specifically over 97% of very liberal moms versus 86% of very conservative moms. Across the political spectrum (ranging from 87% to 91%), Mothers agreed there should be an update of federal laws governing the marketing of age-restricted products, such as e-cigarettes, that address current marketing practices. Over 80% of Mothers agreed that Congress should examine whether social media companies' age gating capabilities are effective, and companies should determine how these capabilities can be strengthened.

Qualitative Questions
When provided an open field to share firsthand experience:
Almost 16% of mothers wrote about being concerned with the easy accessibility of vaping products. Some mothers remarked that they’ve seen teens purchase e-cigarettes/vapes from stores that do not check IDs and other mothers said they’ve known teens to buy e-cigarettes/vapes from adults. Over 11% of mothers felt that increasing education on the effects and addictiveness of vaping would be helpful as a preventative measure. Over 20% of mothers thought that there should be stricter laws regarding e-cigarettes/vapes, including raising the age limit or implementing partial or total bans of e-cigarettes/vapes. For example, a mother from Illinois thought that banning the sales of e-cigarettes/vapes within a certain range of schools would be helpful.

Research Library

Explore Count on Mothers reports — rapid polls and in-depth national studies.

Methodology
Count on Mothers conducts nationwide surveys and qualitative research with U.S. mothers. Findings are analyzed and reported in aggregate to inform research publications and decision-making related to families.
Rapid

Mothers' Views on the Childcare for Working Families Act

In September 2023, Count on Mothers surveyed 354 mothers across 47 states and a broad range of political ideologies to understand parental perspectives on the Child Care for Working Families Act (S.1354). In addition to the national survey, six mothers from conservative, moderate, and liberal backgrounds participated in in-depth interviews to provide qualitative context. Findings were shared with the public and Congressional legislators to inform deliberations on policies affecting children and families. Overall, mothers across the political spectrum expressed strong support for the bill, with some variation by ideology on specific provisions.
September 30, 2023
View Report →
Rapid

Mothers' Views on the FAMILY Act

In August 2023, Count on Mothers surveyed 309 mothers across 41 states and a broad range of political ideologies to understand parental perspectives on the FAMILY (Family and Medical Insurance Leave) Act (S.1714). Mothers shared their views based on first-hand experience with health, caregiving, and work-related leave. The aggregated findings were shared with the public and Congressional legislators to inform deliberations on policies affecting children and families. Overall, mothers across political backgrounds showed strong alignment on core paid leave protections, with some variation on specific provisions.
August 31, 2023
View Report →
Rapid

Parents Bill of Rights

In July 2023, Count on Mothers surveyed 277 mothers across 44 states and a broad range of political ideologies to understand parental views on the Parents Bill of Rights (H.R.5). Mothers responded based on their first-hand experience with public education and family decision-making. The aggregated findings were shared with Congressional legislators to inform deliberations on policies affecting children and families. Overall, mothers across political backgrounds showed strong agreement on many core provisions of the bill, while expressing mixed views on several specific implementation measures.
July 31, 2023
View Report →
Rapid

Mothers' Views on Social Media Legislation

In June 2023, 318 mothers from 44 states and a cross-section of political ideology completed a short anonymous survey and shared their views on the components of the “Protecting Kids on Social Media Act.” We take this aggregate data and share it with Congressional legislators so they are educated while deliberating over this bill. Mothers share their views based on their first-hand experience with the issues the bill seeks to address.
June 30, 2023
View Report →
Interested in commissioning research or receiving a briefing?
Partner With Us